Annabelle's Mom - it depends on a couple of things as to which one you want to pick. Cost is a major factor - you have to figure out your budget and work within that. Also, not every dog will like every food. I have spent the last 10 + years dealing with that problem with my Huskies. Usually what happens, one will like something and the other will hate it and then I switch and it is the other one that hates it! Next, do you want to feed grain free or not.

Many people have recommended the Merrick line of kibble and canned foods although none of my dogs have ever taken to it.

Innova makes a really good line of food and the kibble size is not too bad. They make both a grain free (EVO) and regular kibble and the price point is very reasonable for the qualits.

Wellness also has a small dog formula. They are very reasonably priced and they have been a leader is high quality dog food for quite a few years. Wellness also comes in grain free (Core).

Hopefully your local pet food store can give you some samples or guarantee the food so if your dogs don't like it you can take it back for an exchange or refund.