Sarah, as long as they aren't gaining weight, you're not over feeding.
Toby weighs about 5.4 lbs and only gets about 30 pieces per meal, less than recommended. But he doesn't need more than that. I think every dog is different. And it depends on their activity level (when he goes to day care or on extra long walks he gets appx 10 pieces more per meal).
Sent from my iPhone using Petguide.com App