Oh gosh, I'm not sure I'd be able to decide if I were you. I'd probably have to go see them both, lol. They are so cute. I like the odd markings of the brown and white girl and the cute black spot on her nose. I wish there were more pictures of her. I'd like to see a profile shot. Maybe you should call and ask if they have anymore pictures! And pictures of the parents. That's how I made my decision for Gemma.