Lulu is not crazy about S & C Duck, duck, goose. She will eat it grudgingly. lol There was another one I bought--I think beef, but I would have to look at my buying history to be sure--she wouldn't touch AT ALL. She LOVES S & C Pleasantly pheasant. I say that to say, it may be that one particular type and not all S & C. All of these I'm referring to are freeze dried, but I don't think that matters. Does your store have a return policy you could exchange it for a different flavor?
Life is better because I have a friend like you.